I've been working on my next book, Footprints on the Ceiling. It involves finding all my columns of the past three years, copying and pasting them into one document, grouping them by type, editing out all the stuff that made people mad when they were first published, and giving them titles.
I really am terrible at titles but I don't have a choice. Numbering the chapters doesn't really work for a collection like this.
I also don't have a choice about editing. There's something really torturous about reading your own work over and over again. About the second time through, the little voices start up.
Jane Kirkpatrick calls them the Harpies, the little gremlins that sit on your shoulders and chatter in your ear. "Boring boring boring." "Nobody wants to hear about this." "TMI!" "Cliche!" "Too wordy!" "Too choppy!"
["Too beady, too bumpy, too leafy, too lumpy," as the hat book says that I used to read to the children.]
This is why I sometimes don't read my own books for a couple of years after they're published, and why I am astonished that nice people buy my books and read them. I love you readers, more than I can say.
* * * *
In Goodwill the other day I overheard a conversation between a younger lady and a woman my age. The older woman was the wise-soothing-mentor type, and she was catching up with the younger woman's life.
Younger woman: I left my job at the courthouse. I was tired of pushing papers. I wanted to help low-income people.
Older woman: Well, good for you.
Younger: And I divorced my husband. He just wasn't supportive.
Older: Oh?
Younger: [starts crying] Yeah, he just wasn't supportive. So I divorced him.
Older: Well, you can't waste your life on people who aren't worth your time.
I came home and recounted this conversation to my patient tribe who puts up with their mom overhearing Goodwill conversations and repeating them at home, followed by a 3-point sermon.
Jenny said, "Do I sense a blog post coming on?"
Well, yes. But I've found that if you write a blog post on divorce, you get emails and comments saying, "You have a good man. You don't know what it's like. I had no choice. You don't know what you're talking about. Nobody should have to live like I did."
No one ever says, "Wow, if you've stuck it out for 30 years, one sinner married to another sinner who is opposite in personality, surely you've had to find your way through some tough challenges and had some really hard conversations and made some interesting sacrifices, and yet you seem happy together today. So teach me, Oh Wise One."
They never say that.
So. I will just say this. If you are the sort of person who feels that "not being supportive" is grounds for divorce, maybe you shouldn't bother getting married. Because you are both going to have times when you think your spouse's latest scheme is insane.
* * * * * *
Garrison Keillor wrote about zucchini a few times. He says July is the only time Minnesotans lock their cars in the church parking lot, to keep people from putting their extra zucchini in the back seat.
Minnesota is somewhat limited in the things it will grow. Cherries and peaches and okra do best in other climes, but corn and ground cherries and zucchini do astonishingly well there. Keillor had a great line about zucchini lying there, snuggling quietly under the cool green leaves and growing to the size of beached whales.
Which is what mine are doing these days. I was late getting a garden in and didn't have the best seeds, so the carrots are sparse and 75% of the tomatoes died.
But Oh, Reader, the zucchini. I turn my back for a day or two and then, while hoeing in the vicinity I sweep back the large bristly leaves and there they are, enormous and quiet, cool and green, swollen to the size of baseball bats, sea lions, hippos.
Today Jenny made two loaves of zucchini bread and also liver and onions with zucchini. She didn't even use up one squash. Naturally, she found the recipe for the zucchini bread in the cookbook from my folks' church in Minnesota.
It also has a second zucchini bread recipe, two recipes for zucchini muffins, plus zucchini apple pie, zucchini jam, and a "squash casserole" that takes 3 cups of grated zucchini.
* * *
Matt was home for a few days, thanks to an assignment that took him to the Kitsap Navy Base in Washington, close to where we had gone for our anniversary trip.
Matt and Ben had long, extended arguments about such things as what would have happened to the Blazers if Brandon Roy and Greg Oden hadn't been so plagued with injuries. And whether it would be better to meet a grizzly bear or a black bear if you had only 30 seconds to react.
Each of them will take one side, and they will argue with congenial intensity for a long time, quoting more statistics than you had any idea existed on the subject, and bringing in principles of physics and engineering and calculus, in addition to tidbits of history and finer points of geographical knowledge.
I couldn't hold up my end of such a conversation for three minutes, but I enjoy listening to them.
Quote of the Day:
"They're not poofing so well. Sorry! I'm speaking your language and not my language. Their volume is not increasing as they get hotter."
--Ben, about the frozen marshmallows over the campfire
Remember the old woman who lived in a shoe? I'm a lot like her, with a husband and varying numbers of children in our 100-year-old farmhouse. This blog is about our lives.
Pages
▼
Pages
▼
Pages
▼
Pages
▼
Wednesday, August 20, 2014
Tuesday, August 19, 2014
The Anniversary Trip
Here's last Sunday's Letter from Harrisburg column, plus photos of our trip to Washington.
Marriage built on routine can still take turns of sweet surprise
The Register-Guard
My husband’s phone buzzed at 1:45 a.m., over on the table in the tasteful studio apartment near Puget Sound, where we were spending our 30th anniversary.
I had slept uneasily, with
strange, colorful shapes battling in my dreams. Since the phone
didn’t wake Paul, I got up and answered it.
One wonders, at such times,
what’s wrong back home, who crashed a car, and what’s on fire.
“Hello?”
“Uh yeah, I just got off at
Exit 216, and I’m lookin’ for the Wilton Smucker Warehouse. I
got a load to drop off.”
I thought, groggily, “What
sort of insane truck driver calls at this time of the night?”
He went on. “I went through
this little town, and I’m seein’ a sign that says ‘Harrisburg 3
miles’.”
The world seemed tipped the
wrong way and answering him took a huge effort.
“Did the town just have one
stoplight?” I finally said.
He asked someone beside him,
“Did the town just have one light?”
The someone else didn’t know.
I didn’t know why I’d asked.
I tried to remember where Exit
216 was, but I was distracted by a strange sensation in my
stomach. The valves in my esophagus were opening, from bottom to
top, and a seething something was pushing rapidly up the pipe.
The truck driver was still
loudly demanding that I tell him where he was and where he
should go.
I handed the phone to Paul,
who mercifully was now awake. Then I grabbed a nearby
wastebasket and threw up.
Paul finished directing the
driver while I went to the bathroom and finished what I had
begun.
I had a happy thought in the
middle of this dreadful episode: My life isn’t boring after all.
Even 30 years into this
marriage, the plot takes unscripted turns. How lucky I am.
We found this place through VRBO and stayed in the apartment above the garage. |
I’m not sure where I had
absorbed the idea that married life was boring and single life
was not — maybe from watching my overworked parents and their
peers, stuck in their small circumscribed lives of repetitive
sameness. Oatmeal for breakfast, “singings” at church on Sunday
nights, milking the cows twice a day, green beans in July,
sewing circle on the same Tuesday every month.
It looked like imprisonment to
a 16-year-old eager for adventure, quivering with anticipation
for life in the real world.
When I got married, some years
later and a few degrees wiser, a touch of that fear remained.
Thirty years in, swamped with
blessings, I understand the appeal of sameness, the contentment
of routine, but at this stage they are not often mine to enjoy.
We have six children — four
still at home — my dad with us for the summer, a house in the
country, a business, several jobs, and more remarkable
opportunities than we could ever take on.
Blessings bring responsibility
and responsibility brings work and decisions, and it all leads
to stress that makes you forget how fortunate you are. It’s easy
to focus your stress on the foremost blessing and most
convenient target — your spouse.
So we took off to celebrate
and rest, because our lives could change very quickly, we know
that, and when the dust settles we want to still enjoy each
other’s company.
We chose the Olympic Peninsula
because it intrigued us both and was within a day’s drive. It
proved to be exactly what we needed, the astonishing natural
beauty healing our exhausted souls, the historic sites and local
attractions keeping us busy and entertained.
We went out to a Chinese
restaurant for dinner one night, fortunately not knowing what
would happen a few hours later.
Maybe our lives are still a
little too narrow, because we both like to — subtly, we hope —
observe other people and “figure out the dynamics” as Paul says.
“That group. Is it a family?”
Paul asked. “It’s all ages, but it doesn’t come out right.”
Happily for our curiosity,
they explained it all to the waiter when they left — birthday
child, mom, two grandpas, three aunts. Ah yes, of course.
There was no question about
the nervous couple who sat at the next table, both polished up
for the occasion, eager to please. They talked loudly enough to
let the surrounding guests know that this was their first date,
he was 61, and she was 10 years younger.
Would she like some wine, he
asked. No?
Maybe some tea, she said.
He talked about his ex-wife.
“She liked all this special stuff. I’d drive all over town
trying to find what she wanted. Nothing was good enough.”
The woman said, “Oh, I’m not
like that. Eating a hot dog outside, that’s good enough for me.”
He said, “Really?”
We sat there, 30 years in,
soaking in the joy of familiarity and history and knowing each
other this well, thinking what a burden it would be to have to
start all over.
A cool garnish. |
It was a virus and not the
dinner that made me sick that night, I figured, because by
morning I had a fever.
I slept most of the day,
aching all over like I had camped on rocky ground in a cheap
sleeping bag, but knowing that I didn’t have a single
responsibility waiting for me.
“Can I do anything for you?”
said Paul, who acted restless and confined but refused to go on
the whale-watching excursion without me.
“A back rub,” I suggested,
even though he isn’t the back-rubbing type. Eager to help, he
attacked my spine like he was scrubbing a greasy oven rack.
“No, no,” I said. “You’re a
farmer, spraying a field. You want to make sure all the acreage
is covered.” So he did. Then he drove to McDonald’s and bought
me some iced tea. I drank it and slept again while he worked on
the stack of paperwork he’d brought along.
My 15-year-old daughter called
me. “Oh, Mom, I’m so sorry you’re sick. Is Dad taking good care
of you?”
I told her about the back rub
and the tea.
“Awwww, that’s so sweeeet!”
she gushed, referring to Paul and not the tea. I agreed.
The next day I felt much
better, so we went on a long ferry-and-road route to Whidbey
Island and over to the mainland and then back to the western
side and north to our welcoming little apartment.
On Sunday we went exploring
again, hiking to three waterfalls in the Olympic Mountains and
the relentless sunshine.
Looking down from a bridge on a series of waterfalls. |
Another waterfall. |
We returned on Monday,
replenished, rested, refreshed; knowing each other again; ready
to come back to home and all it entailed.
Back in the daily swirl of
responsibilities, I have a renewed sense of awareness, of
gratitude, of astonishment, even, that I, who asked for and
feared all the wrong things back then, was given this life, this
man, this marriage, this abundance of blessings, these crazy
turns in the story that keep me forever surprised.
Betty MacDonald wrote The Egg and I and the Mrs. Piggy-Wiggle books, among others. She lived along this road. |
Another ferry, with Mt. Baker behind. |
This boat looked like it could tell lots of stories. |
The ferry. It was huge, full of cars down below, with room for hundreds of people up above. |
What do you know--they're serving "me" at Elmer's! |
The Olympic Peninsula scenery is amazing. Ten miles from Puget Sound, the mountains are 6000 feet high. |
We managed a smiling selfie on a hike. |
Port Townsend |
More Port Townsend |
There are all kinds of ships in the bays, and, I'm told, the occasional nuclear submarine heading out to sea. |
A squinting couple on the ferry. |
A cool view while waiting to get on the ferry. |
Maybe this belonged to a relative... |
Tuesday, August 05, 2014
Thoughts on Rest and Marriage and Time
Right after I posted Sunday's tale of my frantic day, it seemed that I kept running across articles on how our society glorifies busy, and how we choose to be busy, and so on.
Hmmm.
Monday turned out to be a day of rest. Steven went to work early and the others slept in, and I happily let them, for the sake of the quiet that resulted.
Dad was up at his normal time, and if you wonder what that is, I will tell you that the other morning he marched into the kitchen at 8:10 and announced, "Ach, ich hap mich veesht fa-schlofa!" which is to say, "I overslept badly."
But after he had his oatmeal he kept himself occupied.
I decided that this is what "Rest" looks like for me:
1. Quiet.
2. Not having to answer questions.
3. Being able to plan and make lists.
4. Being able to think/write/pray/meditate/concentrate.
5. Staying home.
6. Not having to fix other people's disasters or take on their projects.
There are others in the household for whom "rest" looks very different. But we all need it, and I think the purpose of the Sabbath command was to make it intentional.
So, as I said, Monday turned out to be restful, at least for a couple of hours, which was a very kind gift from the Father, and "so refreshing," as the Bingley sister says in Pride and Prejudice.
And the remainder of this week, starting tomorrow, promises to be a rest of a different sort, as Paul and I plan to take off to celebrate our 30th anniversary.
Yes, on August 10th it will be 30 years since we said our vows at Brownsville Church on a hot evening. And in this busy time of year, Paul is taking me up to a cabiny place on Puget Sound, which shows that he is still a very nice guy who invests in his marriage and makes me feel astonishingly valued.
My parents would have celebrated their 60th anniversary this year, which means they were married 30 years when they came out for our wedding. At the time, I thought they were old and out of touch, devoid of romance, stuck in dreadful sequestered isolated lives.
I don't think they saw themselves that way, which makes one wonder about the hidden dynamics of a settled life and a 30-year-old marriage that young people never see.
Mom saw the Pacific Ocean for the first time on that trip, and announced that she's going to get her feet wet in it, so there on the beach she stripped off her black stockings and waded in, laughing, and I was so proud of her, in the sense of Oh look at this adventurous old lady, but really she was just Mom being Mom.
Paul and I are both taking our laptops and piles of paper on this trip, because that is actually one aspect of "rest" for both of us, to spread out our work in a motel room and feel like we're getting caught up.
To each, their own.
I hope to walk the beach and pray about my busy life and how to rearrange it, and about trusting God for his timing and distributing of things I can't control such as church responsibilities and Paul's work load and having lots of single adults at home who haven't yet found someone to say their vows to on a hot August evening. Stuff like that.
This stage will not last forever and it might even be over very quickly, and when the dust settles I want Paul and I to still enjoy each other's company.
So, off to Port Townsend we go.
Hmmm.
Monday turned out to be a day of rest. Steven went to work early and the others slept in, and I happily let them, for the sake of the quiet that resulted.
Dad was up at his normal time, and if you wonder what that is, I will tell you that the other morning he marched into the kitchen at 8:10 and announced, "Ach, ich hap mich veesht fa-schlofa!" which is to say, "I overslept badly."
But after he had his oatmeal he kept himself occupied.
I decided that this is what "Rest" looks like for me:
1. Quiet.
2. Not having to answer questions.
3. Being able to plan and make lists.
4. Being able to think/write/pray/meditate/concentrate.
5. Staying home.
6. Not having to fix other people's disasters or take on their projects.
There are others in the household for whom "rest" looks very different. But we all need it, and I think the purpose of the Sabbath command was to make it intentional.
So, as I said, Monday turned out to be restful, at least for a couple of hours, which was a very kind gift from the Father, and "so refreshing," as the Bingley sister says in Pride and Prejudice.
And the remainder of this week, starting tomorrow, promises to be a rest of a different sort, as Paul and I plan to take off to celebrate our 30th anniversary.
Yes, on August 10th it will be 30 years since we said our vows at Brownsville Church on a hot evening. And in this busy time of year, Paul is taking me up to a cabiny place on Puget Sound, which shows that he is still a very nice guy who invests in his marriage and makes me feel astonishingly valued.
My parents would have celebrated their 60th anniversary this year, which means they were married 30 years when they came out for our wedding. At the time, I thought they were old and out of touch, devoid of romance, stuck in dreadful sequestered isolated lives.
I don't think they saw themselves that way, which makes one wonder about the hidden dynamics of a settled life and a 30-year-old marriage that young people never see.
Mom saw the Pacific Ocean for the first time on that trip, and announced that she's going to get her feet wet in it, so there on the beach she stripped off her black stockings and waded in, laughing, and I was so proud of her, in the sense of Oh look at this adventurous old lady, but really she was just Mom being Mom.
Paul and I are both taking our laptops and piles of paper on this trip, because that is actually one aspect of "rest" for both of us, to spread out our work in a motel room and feel like we're getting caught up.
To each, their own.
I hope to walk the beach and pray about my busy life and how to rearrange it, and about trusting God for his timing and distributing of things I can't control such as church responsibilities and Paul's work load and having lots of single adults at home who haven't yet found someone to say their vows to on a hot August evening. Stuff like that.
This stage will not last forever and it might even be over very quickly, and when the dust settles I want Paul and I to still enjoy each other's company.
So, off to Port Townsend we go.
Sunday, August 03, 2014
A Sunday Evening Wrapup from the Minister's Wife
Somehow, I have missed God’s will for my life. It is Sunday evening and I am not rested.
This morning I got up early and made tea, studied for Sunday school, put potatoes in one crock pot and a beef roast in another, got ready for church, and hollered upstairs at slow people.
By the time we got to church, Jenny had a headache and felt like throwing up. I took her into the rec room, found the first aid kit, took her temperature, and found Emily in the foyer and told her to take Jenny home again.
At church I taught Sunday school and then listened to a missions talk and thought we should go to a certain Southeast Asian country, because the language isn’t tonal, and the team that’s going is all young, and they need someone our age to parent all the high-energy young missionaries. That was my take on it. They were not there to recruit someone like us.
After church I hustled over to the school where we met with the concerned parents of a boy who doesn’t pick up on reading as fast as some. The older I get, the more my advice shifts toward: 1. Chill out. 2. Read to him every day. 3. Let him play outside all day except for meals and chores. 4. Wait until he’s 8 to talk about reading. Or even 9.
No one wants to hear that advice, it seems.
Then I came home and brought Paul’s mom along and put the ice cream goop in the maker and turned it on, and got in Ben and Steven’s way while we all got dinner ready, which was roast beef, mashed potatoes, gravy, corn, tossed salad, blueberry cobbler, ice cream, and tea.
I also tried to make connections with my brother Phil, who had Dad for the weekend. Paul left to go meet them along the freeway and everyone miscommunicated horribly and sent texts to the wrong people and didn’t read the ones they got, but they finally came home, just in time to go to Dan and Martha’s reception, out in the lovely gardens that Dan’s mom creates and sculpts, and where we younger moms looked around with jealousy, because we are doing good if we keep our plants sort of watered and kind of alive in this hot summer.
Then we galloped off to the evening service at church, where Paul preached to a slim crowd on Revelation and the beast with seven heads and ten horns, and the vacation Bible school teachers [Paul, Emily, and a bunch more] got prayed for and started setting up their classrooms, and I talked with Pauline about the picnic meal at the end of VBS next Saturday and tried to find willing people to make baked beans for 30 people each.
Steven drove us home and I typed a few more numbers into my new phone while Emily found flaws in the Companions story from years ago that someone gave her.
The boys unloaded the dishwasher and Ben talked about the Mongol empire, which was one of the biggest, longest ever, which his dad had failed to mention in the sermon as a possibility for one of the heads on the beast.
I checked on Jenny who is better but not well.
Now it is the end of Sunday and I do not feel rested, and the week ahead is about to hit like a tsunami. I don’t think this was God’s idea for a day of rest. Or is Sunday more about “keep it holy” than about “in it thou shalt not do any work”??
Or maybe there’s a verse in Hezekiah that says, “And the wives and mothers among you, especially those of the preacher’s household, shall not rest on the Sabbath, neither by day or night, or on the afternoon thereof. And verily they shall feed at their table the flesh of cattle at midday, the fruit of the vine, and pottage, to all the inhabitants thereof. And on the scroll shall they write the prayer requests of the congregation, yea, all the infirmities thereof, even unto the embarrassing personal ones, and if they by the hearing of the ears are told secrets such as would tingle the ears of the hearers from Dan to Beersheba, yet shall they remain silent, though the tales burn within them. And even into old age shall the wives remember who didst attend at the worship of the Lord in the morning and evening assembly, and who didst absent themselves, and shall telephone them in the days to come, to enquire therein, whether they be ill, or whether a root of bitterness at another member or the pastor’s sermons troubleth them, or whether they remained in their dwelling to make merry in the company of their fellows, and to roast the meat of cattle on the coal that burneth with fire in the grill of iron."
[“At least it’s in King James,” says Jenny.]
{Actually I do NOT call people up to see why they weren't at church. But I feel like a good minister's wife should at least notice they're gone, which I don't usually do.}
--*--*--*
The longer Dad is here, the more I believe in multi-generational households, and the more I wish we could have had an arrangement like this 5 or 10 years ago, for Mom and Dad, with their own space close by, and me making sure they were clean and fed, and them teaching Jenny Pa. Dutch, and both of them going out to talk to the cats and keep the calves watered.
The other day I said, “When we’re old, please have us live in a dawdi haus*.”
The children immediately kicked into Clever mode.
“Actually we’ll have a Nawdi haus!”
“Cuz Mom’s gonna be naughty!” [ha ha ha ha ha!!]
“Yeah, she’ll make Trim Healthy Mama food and try to fool us
with it.”
“And she’ll give us tons of secondhand baby clothes and we’ll be like, put it on the baby, take a picture, send it to mom, give the clothes to Goodwill,”
SIGH.“And she’ll give us tons of secondhand baby clothes and we’ll be like, put it on the baby, take a picture, send it to mom, give the clothes to Goodwill,”
*dawdi haus: a little house for the grandparents, on the same property as the main family dwelling.
&++&++&++
The kids are talking about getting me a t-shirt with a platypus on it, which I guess is the official cross of a beaver and a duck.
Ben will be the resident Beaver, since he just got accepted into Oregon State’s engineering school.
Emily will be the local Duck, since she’s going to the University of Oregon, hoping to get into the school of journalism winter term.
Both Ben and Emily completed their first two years at Linn-Benton Community College, where they both got astonishing GPA’s. [bragged Mother.]
They would also come home and discuss, with great hoots and mockery, the older students on campus who carried their books in ROLLING backpacks.
Yes, I am serious. There were actually college students who were so old that they cared more about their aching backs than the screaming un-cool-ness of backpacks that—gales of laughter—rolled!
Me: You do realize that if I went back to college I would use a rolling case for my books.
Em and Ben: Yes, Mom. We know. It’s ok if it’s someone your age. What looks so ridiculous is when a younger person does it.
SIGH again.
^^^___&&&
Since I am utterly frozen with fear at writing a novel, plus I don’t have time, I try to write a one-sentence story a day, just to start thawing.
It’s fun.
“The crowded marigolds made Frances feel understood.”
“Charles drove a stacker and wished he could drive a truck.”
“Darlene knew why Edwin always avoided Cartney Drive.”
AND.
I have a title for my 5th collection of newspaper columns:
“FOOTPRINTS ON THE CEILING.”
Someone suggest this, but they commented anonymously, so I
don’t know who it was.
Quote of the Day”
“I just suddenly got curious—at what temperature would the
human body melt?”
--Emily, who has the unfortunate combination of college
knowledge plus hours alone on the combine
Friday, August 01, 2014
Letter from Harrisburg: Fred, the Moon, and Me
Trust, suspicion and finding men on the moon
By Dorcas Smucker
For The
Register-Guard
The first moon landing, 45
years ago last Sunday, must have been a very big deal,
because we actually found out about it.
Or, at least, my brother Fred
did.
A lot of minor news slipped
past us when we were Amish, since we didn’t have a TV
or radio, and we bought a newspaper only sporadically.
We five children shared a big
bedroom upstairs in that old farmhouse in 1969, and
that night Fred knelt by the tall, narrow window and
gazed at the moon in the sky above the buggy shed.
Fred always gave you the
feeling that he was in on something mysterious and
astonishing. If you were really lucky, and really nice
to him, he just might let you in on the secret.
“Yes,” he said. “I think I
see something.”
We rushed to the window, my
8-year-old sister Rebecca and I, a year younger.
Fred was 11. He knew
everything. He said, “People landed on the moon today.
I think ... yes, I’m pretty sure I see little black
dots moving around on the moon.”
Really?
We leaned in and looked hard
at that big white moon. We squinted and focused and
pretty soon we exclaimed that ... Yes! There they
were! We could see them too!
To this day, I don’t know if
he had fooled himself as thoroughly as he fooled us.
Much later, disillusioned, we learned to be suspicious
of anything Fred told us, after he had convinced me
that the pig pellets in the feed room were good to
snack on, Rebecca that he and she were actually twins,
and my little sister Margaret that pennies smelled
like pig manure.
It is comforting that
everyone who knows Fred tells similar stories of
believing the most improbable things, simply because
he said it in such a way that you felt stupid and
unkind if you didn’t believe him.
He once worked on a dairy
farm and pocketed a diseased tooth that a veterinarian
pulled from a cow. Providentially, he had a wisdom
tooth pulled soon after.
The owner’s wife offered her
sympathies when he returned to work after his dentist
visit. Fred said, all seriously, “Would you like to
see the tooth they pulled?” and pulled out the cow
tooth, a vicious-looking specimen with curved roots 2
inches long.
He convinced the woman it had
actually come from his mouth. He still has that
mysterious magic that makes you want to believe
everything he says.
I’ve found that the world is
full of people like Fred. Not as charming, perhaps,
but just as able to make you feel silly if you don’t
believe them.
To be informed on current
issues to any degree is to be almost forced to form an
opinion, so while I would like to walk the narrow path
of reason and truth, I often find myself in one ditch
or another — overly trusting and gullible, or
unnecessarily skeptical and suspicious.
Health, medicine, science,
finances, politics, parenting, religion and many more
examples — all have spokespeople who seem determined
to persuade the rest of us to alter our lives to their
theories. For every multi-degreed expert presenting
his case as truth so obvious and verified you couldn’t
possibly believe otherwise, there’s a counter-voice
urging suspicion of experts with hidden agendas and
guesses presented smoothly as fact.
Strangely, while the Amish
are sometimes a bit too eager to believe the claims of
alternative medicine and similar fields, many of them
were skeptical about the moon landings. I lived with
an elderly Amish bishop and his wife after high
school, and Noah with his deep preaching voice would
hold forth on the subject. “They say they put ‘de
mensha’ on the moon,” he’d bellow, “but it was all
made up.”
Then he’d talk confidently
about how they staged the scene to make the moonscape
look real and took the pictures, even though he had
never used a camera in his life.
Perhaps it’s because the
Amish have been fighting the cultural current for
centuries that I learned in that context to be
suspicious of otherwise well-respected experts in
science and government.
Or maybe it’s my age, having
seen experts proved wrong.
Bankers in the 1970s urged
Midwestern farmers to take out enormous loans and buy
equally enormous equipment. This was how modern
farming was done, they said. Tragically, many of these farmers
crashed and burned financially in the early ’80s.
When my friends and I were
having babies, our doctors always told us that no,
there was no way that teething caused fevers.
But we were the ones up at
night with fussy, feverish babies who recovered
magically when their upper incisors popped through,
plus we had a lot more babies than any of our doctors
did. So we took their expert advice with a grain of
salt and gave the counsel of experienced moms equal
weight.
We learned about the four
food groups in home ec in high school, and later the
side of every cereal box told us that low-fat food was
the way to be healthy, so we nibbled on pretzels for
years, feeling tired and hungry, and then lost weight
and felt healthier when we switched to steak and
butter and veggies.
As a mom, minister’s wife and
writer, I often think about influence and what it
takes to change someone’s mind. What makes us form a
belief? What solidifies it? What makes us change it?
For many people, including
myself, it isn’t facts and logic that make the
difference. Experience and emotion and relationships
are the stronger influences. You don’t win the
argument by making the other side look stupid.
I “saw” the astronauts on the
moon because I wanted so badly to be as cool as my
brother. Later, the humiliation of being fooled
multiple times outweighed the satisfaction of being in
on his schemes.
Today, I am slow to believe
any of Fred’s stories. I squint at him just as I
squinted at the moon years ago, but now with careful
analysis — true or not true? Hmmm.
This pains him deeply, he
says, playing on my compassion with large, sad eyes.
It worked when I was 7 but fails to affect me now.
If emotions and experience
make the difference, then, most of the time, nothing I
say will change anyone’s mind, so I seldom engage in
debate.
Plus, I have a burdensome
ability to understand all sides of an issue and why
people believe as they do.
Most things are not worth
arguing about, and in 10 years many of the most
outspoken among us will look really silly, time having
proven them wrong. If you keep your opinions to
yourself, you can quietly change your views as time
goes on without having to endure the pain of publicly
backtracking.
My faith is important to me
and, as a believer, I’ve been accused of ignoring the
facts. I understand this viewpoint. Yet, the deep-down
intangibles are even more real and true to me —
conscience, forgiveness, hope. How do you debate such
concepts?
My influence depends largely
on how I make people feel, a discouraging concept for
noisy debaters but comforting to people like me, who
hate arguments but would love to turn everyone down
the path of kindness and responsibility, simplicity
and faith.
I will no doubt believe the
wrong people for the wrong reasons at times, and then
wise up and change my mind, as long as I live. And so
will everyone around me.
What I want to remember is
that we are all a lot like that little 7-year-old girl
looking at the moon: persuaded more by emotions than
facts, more by empathy than condescension, and more by
experience than information.
Others will be influenced
more by who we are than by anything wise and logical
we might say.